In the poem “Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening” the beloved American poet, Robert Frost, describes an idyllic New England scene, as he “watch(es) his woods fill up with snow…” and praises “the easy wind and downy flake”. Ha! Come shovel my driveway, Mr. Frost. There are no “downy flakes” here. Just mounds of heavy, wet, icy snow to strain my back. And worse, that snow also covers my backyard deck. When I finish clearing my driveway in 2 hours, must I then shovel off my deck? Actually: You don’t. Really? My aching back likes that answer.
♦ Don’t shovel your deck to avoid collapse. Building Codes require decks support more snow than most roofs. A properly built deck is not likely to collapse from the weight of snow. Read the engineering details in my blog post last month or just skip to the conclusion: “Here’s a rule of thumb: Your deck rails are probably 36” high. Don’t worry until the snow is above your rails (deeper than 3 feet.) If you can see the rail tops, you’re OK — even with a little rain.” When snow is deeper than 3 feet, begin to worry. When snow is deeper than 3-1/2 feet, begin to shovel.
♦ Don’t shovel your deck to protect the wood. Water and snow are not nearly as harsh on wooden decks as some TV advertisers would have you believe. Indeed, in the south many experts recommend cooling wood decks on very hot days with water – turn on the hose and spray away. High summer temperatures and the drying sun cause deck boards to cup and misbehave. If you are skeptical, consider wood’s natural state: within trees, wood is moist or even wet and must be “seasoned” (dried out) before use. And rot? That’s why you built your deck of rot proof wood or plastic.
♦ Don’t shovel your deck to protect the synthetic decking. The plastic in these decks is impervious to snow. Cold winter temperatures may shrink plastic a little, but it expands back once warmer temperatures return.
♦ Do clear the snow to provide an exit path from your house. You should always have two separate exit paths from your house for safety. Indeed, Building Codes require two. If clearing that second exit path dictates you shovel some of your deck, then do it. But all you need clear is a path 3ft wide; no need to shovel the entire deck. Pay particular attention to your stairs and the hand rails — the “banisters” or “grab rails” — you’ll need to grab those quickly if you slip.
♦ Do clear the snow to provide a path to your grill if you cook outside during the winter, or a path to the bird feeder, to feed your winged friends.
♦ Do shovel the snow if you want the exercise. I guess you could call it exercise — if you are young. But by middle age, I’d call it work.
♦ (Feb 2015) Do shovel your deck when the accumulated snow exceeds 3 ½ ft and you suspect the deck’s structure may be sub-par. Until recently, that much snow had been reserved for Canadians, but suddenly Americans can enjoy it as well. This afternoon my deck outside Boston has over four feet of the white stuff, with the promise of another foot in a few days.
♦ (Oct 2015) Last winter Mother Nature brought record cold and record snow (over nine feet of the stuff) to the Boston area. It also brought us a new warning: Do not dump snow from a roof onto your deck. Several feet of heavy, compact roof snow, thrown on top of an already snow-covered deck can severely damage it – whether you throw it onto the deck or Mother throws it on.
Remember what your high school physics teacher said about the force of falling objects? Force = Mass x Acceleration. Well, “Mass” here is the snow from your roof and “Acceleration” is the speed it gains falling toward your deck. The resulting “Force” can be massive, especially for compacted snow. The greater the height of the fall, the greater the resulting force on your deck. Here’s a deck below a second story roof at the end of last winter:
A worse threat is falling ice. Its impact may be localized, but it is heavier and does not compress when it hits your deck. Instead, your deck compresses…and breaks. Here is a damaged rail and what remains of the culprit:
If snow can damage your deck, is ice even worse? Find out in my article about ice.
Yes, winter can damage your deck.
As I showed in a related blog article, 3 ½ feet of snow weighs somewhere between 42 and 63 pounds per square foot. That’s right at the Building Code’s design load for decks — 40 or 60 psf, depending on your location. Construction standards include a safety factor of 2.5 to 1. That means a deck perfectly built to 40 psf will not fail until 100 psf. So is your deck safe under 6 or 7 feet of snow? No. With snow between 3 ½ feet and 8 feet, your deck — and you — survive in the limbo of that safety margin. Any imperfections in that deck — knots, splits in the wood, sloppy carpentry, weak nails instead of screws, wood that has dried and shrunk — reduce the deck’s safety. Indeed, weight above that 40 or 60 psf design load brings you not into a safety zone but into a danger zone.
Ok then, you’ve decided to clear that thick white menace from your deck. How best to avoid damaging your deck? Here are some TIPS:
1. Before it snows, make sure there are no nails or screws protruding from the flooring; these can catch a shovel or a foot.
2. The best way to clear a little snow is with a broom. A simple corn broom is best. It works well if the snow is fairly light and only a few inches deep. Light, fluffy snow is ideal, for you can sweep it under the rails; and, more importantly, the broom will not scrape, scratch or gouge your deck. And a corn broom will not catch on any protruding nails or screws.
4. When the snow is deep – say, over four inches – you’ll need a shovel. Use a plastic shovel with a plastic blade. A metal blade can easily scratch or gouge your deck. Be especially gentle if your deck flooring is cedar or redwood; they are soft woods and most vulnerable to damage. Pressure treated pine is OK; hard woods like mahogany and especially ipe will fare better, but all wood is vulnerable. And so is composite decking, which is composed of wood and plastic. The newer PVC decking (Azek, TimberTech XLM, Fiberon Horizon, etc) is scratch resistant and will survive a plastic shovel. Note that the manufacturers here do not claim their decking is scratch proof, so some care is still needed.
6. Never chop ice on your deck, even with a plastic shovel. You’re guaranteed to also chop your deck. Instead, melt the ice with chemicals. Use chemical power rather than muscle power. There are numerous choices for wood and synthetic decks. Rock salt or halite works by lowering the freezing temperature of water down to 15 degrees. Calcium chloride* is more effective; it interacts with ice and snow to create heat that melts ice down to 25 degrees below zero. Synthetic decking manufacturers recommend both. Happy Paws ™ snow melter claims to be safer than calcium chloride for pets and the environment.
So if you need to or want to, sweep, blow, or shovel that snow. Just be careful not to scratch or damage your deck, and be especially careful walking on your deck afterward. Ice has a way of creeping back for revenge.
NOTES: * Calcium Chloride is sold under many brand names, including “Safe Step”, “Winter Heat”, “Safe-T-Power”, “Quick Joe” and is available during the winter at hardware stores, lumber yards, and even super markets. More information about ice melting products is available at Cleanlink and Morton Salt.
We at Advantage Design & Construction offer professional design and build services for clients west and north of Boston. Over the past 23 years we have designed and built over 800 projects. We have enhanced the depth of our expertise by limiting our work to decks, porches, sunrooms, and patios. To view some of these projects, visit our website. To learn how we treat our clients, check us on Angie’s List or read a recent article about us in Remodeling Magazine. For a free design consultation and a relaxed and rewarding design and construction experience, contact us via e-mail, firstname.lastname@example.org or by phone, 781-273-3500. © 2011, 2015 Advantage Design & Constr., Inc.